BC Environment Minister Terry Lake addresses his government's ever-changing stance on Enbridge amid what has been a perplexing couple of weeks on the environment in BC(photo: Ward Perrin , PNG)

Enbridge Flip-Flops, LNG Pipeline, New Salmon Farm in Clayoquot Perplexing

Share

Today is a day of perplexity.

I’m perplexed at a notice I received asking me to join a protest against a proposed Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) pipeline near Smithers. This line is designed to transport northeast BC natural gas from a junction point at Summit Lake, north of Prince George, to Kitimat for processing into LNG so it can be shipped to Asian markets. It has flown largely beneath the radar, perhaps because the NDP Opposition haven’t opposed it.

What are the risks posed? Are we talking wildlife migration paths? Do spills pose a threat? Who is doing it and what sort of approvals do they require? When was the application? Were there public meetings, and if so where and what was the reaction?
 
I’m perplexed at the provincial government’s apparent imminent approval of a new fish farm in Clayoquot Sound. How can this possibly be done before the Cohen Commission report comes out? Has no one in that catastrophic government in Victoria read the recent and growing evidence of serious disease endemic to fish farms? It strikes me that approving a fish farm before Mr Justice Cohen issues his report is like Israel building houses on conquered land – an effort to create faits accompli on the theory that once approved, it will be difficult to dismantle them.
 
This government is not only incompetent – we can recover from that – but without a conscience or a soul, without the ability to know right from wrong.
 
I’m perplexed at the flip in the recent opinion column by the Vancouver Sun’s Barbara Yaffe on the proposed Enbridge pipeline. Several weeks ago, after months of approving the proposition, Barbara concluded, on the evidence that had recently come out on the company’s disastrous spill in the Kalamazoo River, that it was unsafe to build the line.
 
Today (July 31) she’s talking about the parties sitting down and negotiating about money to be paid to BC.
 
In the Vancouver Sun, same edition, Craig McInnes, who’s bringing some common sense to that paper, makes the obvious but little stated observation that with the Enbridge pipeline: “A, there is a risk and B, we are willing to accept the risk of a catastrophic spill if we get paid enough.”
 
He goes on to say, “As a Canadian who treasures our physical environment regardless of where the political boundaries lie, I find that equation to be unacceptable.”
 
Amen.
 
Then I’m perplexed with former federal Environment Minister David Anderson’s approval of Premier Clark demanding more money for a project Anderson has just stated his unchangeable opposition to.
 
Mr. Anderson, I know you don’t like me from another movie, but please take my advice and read Mr. McInnes’ column referred to above.
 
I’m perplexed that no one seems to care about Kinder Morgan’s proposed massive increase to pipeline volumes and tanker traffic through Vancouver in environmental terms.
 
I’m also perplexed that Premier Clark isn’t also claiming a greater share of the revenue from the Kinder Morgan lines, existing and, if approved, future lines.
 
I will be dealing with Clark’s position in next Monday’s TheTyee.ca but suffice it to say that in Canada we have free passage of goods and resources through neighbouring provinces. Ms. Clark evidently, to add to the sum of her massive ignorance, doesn’t understand that and fails to put herself in Alberta Premier Redford’s shoes and fails to ask what she, Clark, would do if Alberta demanded a share of BC royalties and stumpage on our resources in exchange for passage through Alberta.
 
In the non-perplexed department I commend Grand Chief Stewart Phillip’s clear and unequivocal stand against Enbridge and his statement that First Nations will, if the project is approved, blockade it.
 
Frankly, I’m perplexed that we’re still debating these issues and that our governments haven’t put an end to them, once and for all.

Share

About Rafe Mair

Rafe Mair, LL.B, LL.D (Hon) a B.C. MLA 1975 to 1981, was Minister of Environment from late 1978 through 1979. In 1981 he left politics for Talk Radio becoming recognized as one of B.C.'s pre-eminent journalists. An avid fly fisherman, he took a special interest in Atlantic salmon farms and private power projects as environmental calamities and became a powerful voice in opposition to them. Rafe is the co-founder of The Common Sense Canadian and writes a regular blog at rafeonline.com.

14 thoughts on “Enbridge Flip-Flops, LNG Pipeline, New Salmon Farm in Clayoquot Perplexing

  1. Hello there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative.
    I’m gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in future. A lot of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  2. Today a lot linked people get a payday loan so that you help them discover through a tough patch.
    Be lent only the price of money families really need.
    Those people loans are out there at reasonable interest rate by some sort of online lenders.

  3. For how the same motive on-line amenities are appreciated by consumers.
    The precondition is that the loan plus attract is paid support on the upcoming pay day.
    Pay day loans are a lot advertised by corporations agencies online.

  4. A helpful individual’s credit fico will not grow to be affected whatsoever when taking out an pawn shop loans.
    For consumers who have need to put cash quick following that a pay daytime loan is by far the a lot of convenient method is doing so.

  5. Believers do not believe in charging not fair interest on some
    type of homeowner loan. Of late a lot towards people get a good solid payday loan that would help them make
    through a coarse patch. For course these companies do not really would like this.

  6. Actually its a great time for them to be doing these things. People are so focused on the other things, well no one is paying attention. Its like the magicians. You look at one hand, while they do the trick with the other hand.

    In my opinion this won’t be the only time they play this “trick”. They know they are going out of office so they want to ensure their “friends” have everything they need prior to their exit.

  7. I would like to know how people feel about fishfarmers saying a Norweigen disease (IHN) occurs naturally in our wild salmon…this is realy sad

  8. I’m perplexed as to why the 99% aren’t out in the streets by the tens of thousands protesting, resisting, denouncing the HarperCONS. Wake up people!

  9. It is ALL so unecessary, there IS free energy, always has been, however they cannot BILL you for it, and so it REMAINS underground, scuz the pun.. We ALL live in an electric universe, and it has been KNOWN for SOME time. It’s not science fiction, ask Tesla, opps, ask, well look into it. Shocking in it’s promotion of that elite 1%. Agenda 21?
    There is no such thing as a conspiracy, what else could hold this popstand together, need more than just one ..

  10. The Pacific Trail Pipeline was approved in April. This Fracking Pipeline is planned to carry gas from the fracking fields in eastern and northeastern BC to Kitimat, It’s breaking trail for Enbridge; both pipelines would carry toxins along the same route for hundreds of kilometers across rivers, wetlands, and wildlife habitat.

    Indigenous people in the path of the pipelines are refusing access to the company, which plans to start work next week. The action camp starts on Monday. Members of the Wet’suwet’en First Nation are asking for solidarity to stop the bulldozing of the pipeline route across Northern BC to Kitimat this fall. Hundreds of people from BC, Ontario, Alberta, Colorado and NW US are taking part in the action camp.

    More info: http://wildcoast.ca/caravan

  11. Its called a petro -state Rafe.

    Oil is the elixir of perpetual war and any good petro state finds itself fully immersed in the politics of war.

    Which dictates war time communications and, as we all know, at times of war truth is the first casualty.

    The agenda is fully camouflaged in a thick dark fog of oily rhetoric and politicians capitalize on lies and deceit while the populous repressed and fleeced.

    Get used to it.

Comments are closed.